Compare the Gear Set You Can Actually Use
Open your Great Vault, export a fresh SimulationCraft profile, and compare the detected rewards in Raidbots Top Gear before claiming an item. The useful question is which available choice improves your complete setup for the content you play. Item level alone cannot answer it.
This guide covers supported DPS simulations for Retail WoW. It does not rank healing throughput or tank survivability, and it does not promise a particular item will be your best reward before your character and choices are imported.
Export Your Character and the Available Rewards
- Update and enable SimulationCraft. Use the addon linked in Raidbots’ installation guide. Log into the character and activate the DPS specialization and talents you want to evaluate.
- Open the Great Vault in game and let its available rewards load. Leave the choice unclaimed while you compare it.
- Run
/simcin chat. Copy the entire export window, including the commented bag-item and weekly-reward sections. Do not copy only your equipped items. - Open Raidbots Top Gear. Use the SimC Addon import and paste the export. Check that the character, specialization and reward items match what you see in game.
Refresh the export after changing gear or talents. The addon reads your current character directly; an Armory lookup can be stale and does not provide the same inventory detail. Use the plain /simc command if you want bag alternatives included: /simc nobags deliberately leaves bag gear out.
Set Up a Comparison That Answers Your Question
Select the relevant Vault candidates along with the equipped pieces and plausible bag alternatives that could change the winning set. Include the pieces needed to test a set-bonus arrangement or a weapon swap. Review the recommended combination as a whole, and confirm it uses only one reward from this week’s Vault.
Choose simulation settings deliberately. A single-target Patchwerk result answers a different question from a multi-target comparison. Keep buffs, duration and other assumptions consistent between candidates. If you play both raid and dungeons, examine more than one relevant scenario instead of treating a single boss setup as a complete dungeon model.
Raidbots documents unsupported or unreliable fight styles, including problems some specializations have with Dungeon Slice. Follow current recommendations from your spec’s maintainers when the site warns that a model is unsupported. Increasing precision cannot repair an unsuitable model.
Keep the first comparison manageable. Select meaningful item alternatives, run Find Top Gear, then narrow the decision. Raidbots’ simulation-time guidance identifies large combination counts and replacing every existing gem or enchant as common reasons for long runs.
Read the Result Before Picking the Highest Number
Inspect the winning set and compare it with your equipped baseline. Check the talents, gems, enchants and other item swaps accompanying the Vault reward. If the improvement relies on changes you cannot make, that result is not yet an actionable upgrade for your character.
| What the report shows | What to inspect before claiming |
|---|---|
| A higher-item-level piece loses | Check the complete set, including any set bonus, weapon pairing or other gear swap. Do not replace the simulated combination with a one-slot guess. |
| A reward wins only after an upgrade | Verify the modeled rank and the currency or materials you can actually spend. Compare an affordable version as well. |
| Two choices are extremely close | Read the sidegrade grouping and error margin. Then weigh practical use, off-spec value and how soon each slot may be replaced. |
| The winner changes between scenarios | Decide which content you are gearing for. Preserve both report setups so the tradeoff remains visible. |
| A trinket result is surprising | Check the full gear set, fight assumptions and on-use ordering before assuming the item itself is misvalued. |
Raidbots groups statistically close results as sidegrades. Its explanation defines that grouping using the simulation’s error, with roughly 0.1% as the usual high-precision example. That is not a universal rule that every difference below a fixed number is meaningless; read the actual report’s precision.
Fix the Baseline Warning Before Comparing Bonus Rolls
A Great Vault run can discover a better arrangement of gear already in your bags. Raidbots warns that the Vault-item and socket comparisons can then use that optimized setup while bonus-roll comparisons still use your currently equipped gear.
Its recommended baseline fix is to equip the suggested current gear and talents, export again, and rerun the Great Vault comparison. Apply this when the notice appears and you can make the recommended setup. Comparing rewards against different baselines can make the apparent gains misleading.
If Rewards or Gear Are Missing
Return to the open Vault, wait for the items to load, and create a new export with the updated addon. Confirm that you pasted the whole text and that rewards remain available to claim.
The addon’s weekly-reward export writes a section headed ### Weekly Reward Choices when rewards are available. Look for actual item lines beneath it. A header with no usable items is not proof that Raidbots received your choices; currency-only rewards are not equippable item candidates.
If your specialization or a fight style is unsupported, resolve that warning before relying on a result. Raidbots’ spec-support guidance explains that SimC focuses on damage: party healing is not quantified, and survival metrics are generally unreliable.
Make the Final Choice in Game
Before claiming, match the item’s exact version and upgrade state with the report, check the complete recommended set, and decide whether the modeled scenario matches your priorities. A small DPS difference may leave room for durability, utility, an off-spec need or a more useful long-term slot.
Use the simulation to understand the tradeoff. Claim the reward after that comparison, then equip and re-export your actual final setup for future runs. If you want to plan later drops instead, Droptimizer answers that separate question; it does not replace comparing the rewards already in your Vault.




